"Thou shall not bear false witness."
Exodus 20:19 and Deuteronomy 5:20
State governments are holding fake electors to account.
A grand jury in Arizona joined Wisconsin, Michigan, Nevada, and Georgia in indicting the people who swore falsely that they were "duly elected and qualified Electors for President and Vice President of the United States from the State of Arizona." The indictment.
My lawyer-friends have given me casual advice over the decades: Never create a false document. This wasn't moral or spiritual advice. It was legal advice. The document is there, on paper, mute, permanent, and available for close examination. It is what it is. Don't sign something false. It will haunt you, they warned.
The 11 people who gathered in Phoenix were not "duly elected." The presidential votes had been counted. Arizona courts had reviewed multiple claims of fraud and error and found nothing of consequence. Arizona's Republican governor certified that Biden had won the popular vote and therefore the election.
A grand jury indicted them on four counts of conspiracy, fraud, and forgery. The indictment described a multi-state plan to allow Vice President Pence to consider two slates of supposedly equally valid ballots. He might discard both slates, and that would throw the election to the House of Representatives, where Trump would win.
The plan required Republican partisans in seven battleground states to sign a certificate of election asserting they were "duly elected." Electors in five of the seven states did so, Arizona's among them. Electors in two states, Pennsylvania and New Mexico, resisted and insisted on inserting language that said their election was contingent on courts, in fact, finding them to be duly elected. Electors in those two states are not in trouble.
The fake-elector scheme hinged on the willingness of citizens to sign their names on a document asserting something untrue. Their being "duly elected" was an aspiration, something almost true. But it wasn't true.
There is a vibe in the current moment and zeitgeist that says that elections don't count. Someone painted that in front of the Jackson County elections office right after the 2020 election.
Trump asserts that cheating is the national norm, that elections past and in the future have been and will be rigged, so cheat first or cheat later. Assert victory and stick to that. That norm is dangerous for a republic. A republic needs norms and expectations that rules and laws are enforced and that good people -- people worthy of public trust -- obey the law and would be ashamed to be caught in a lie.
I am happy that the people who signed their names to false election documents are in serious trouble. They lied. I expect it will be a deterrence to others.
Heads up:
This blog post is a prelude to what I expect will be subsequent posts on telling the truth in the Oregon Voters Pamphlet. It is morally wrong to mislead voters about one's qualifications for office. But there is one place where it is also illegal to do so, the Voters Pamphlet’s top section on education and occupation. Here is the warning to candidates preparing their Oregon Voters Pamphlet candidate statement, page 10:
Would anyone be so foolish as to misstate one's job history in the face of that warning?
[Note: Readers who wish to get this blog daily by email need not fear subscribing. Please do. That is how one gets the blog regularly, sent to your in-box. I won’t ask you to switch to paid. You don’t get put on anybody’s mailing list. No one knows if you read a blog post all the way to the end.]
I want these folks prosecuted to the full extent of the law. I regret that Co-conspirator #1 is unindicted (in this case, so far). And not merely because some Bronze-Age moralist detested dishonesty, but because such dishonesty is a toxin within the body politic.
Thanks much for the indictment copy. Perhaps some of these supposedly intelligent people, who were so easily swayed, will see the error of their ways and incriminate the blacked-out criminals, thugs, and unpatriotic ne'er-do-wells.